If the sensor wire is grounded, but there is power to the gauge, then it will peg all the way to the right. I would try removing some of the sensor wires from the gauges, that should get you pegged all the way left. Sounds as though there is a miswire in the sensor leads.
Check the obvious stuff, from return (ground) at the panel to hot, should be 12 V., that each gauge is getting power, that each gauge has a ground. The ground is on the gauge only for the sake of the light, make sure it is not connected to the sensor wire S instead.
With the sensor wire disconnected from the gauge and the power off, measure the resistance between the sensor wire and ground. It should be anywhere from 33 to 240 ohms, probably somewhere in the middle. If not, follow the wire back to the sensor.
When you have two stations, you have a sender that varies from 17 ohms to 120 ohms, so that it can power two gauges. The S terminal on both gauges should go to the sensor. There is a terminal block somewhere where they come together. Terminal blocks are good places for miswires.
1975 32' Flybridge Sedan, twin Perkins 6-354 diesels, 1:1.53 velvetdrives, 16 X 19 props. Merritt Island, Florida