Hi Doug,
I am the designer of SeaBis System and have been asked to clarify. Thank you for your honest appraisal.
Firstly I am pleased to meet someone who has done the due diligence. The following explanations are a little lengthy, but have to be to explain matters correctly.
To respond to your points:
1.“I think that the true measure of value is what you GET with a purchase, not what it might cost if you don't get it.” Of course totally agree with you and to be honest with you most products have been costed in accordance with their design, production, assembly and packaging etc and one would hope the value for dollar would be determined by product price and cost savings.
The SeaBis unit uses a microprocessor (small dedicated computer) to get accuracy and safety,
Accuracy. The microprocessor automatically adjusts threshold levels for 12 volt or 24 volt systems. The reason is 24 volt boats are generally larger so have a much greater wet metal area to pass the stray current. Accuracy on a 12 volt vessel is 0.0001 amp. We flash red Critical, on a 12 volt boat at 1 milliamp (0.001 amp – you will be able to see the electrolysis within 3 months.
Through to Amber - Caution at 0.00025 amp – you will be barely able to see electrolysis in one year.
To Green – Normal. The stray current is far too low to cause electrolysis – ever.
Safety. SeaBis limits the flow of stray current through itself to 2 mAmps -0.002amp. So ensuring absolute safely. It is dual fused so no matter what fault is present, irrespective of its use, no harm can occur - ever.
The VOM, or any multimeter whatsoever, used on voltage cannot indicate stray current. It can indicate the potential for current to flow. Not the actual current.
If used on milli amps, assuming the defects are on the negative side of the battery and you place the meter from the positive side to the wet metal. It will indicate stray current.
There are two problems:All the defects are in parallel with the meter so will share the current. Very inaccurate. You are effectively placing a short across the battery through the meter in your hands. This is extremely dangerous and results in far too many battery explosions every year. The battery generate hydrogen gas – as was used in the Zeppelins, all of which exploded in a fire ball.
For full explanations on using a multimeter of any make, type or model see
http://www.seabis.com.au/tips.html and scroll down the page to multimeter.
2. Electrical Isolation of engine and propulsion. “wet metal”
The one current path not isolated is the manifold/s. Cooling water through the sea to the seabed.
A bit technical but here goes: Resistance in fresh water, where the voltage difference is 12 volts, as is normal from manifolds to the seabed, is one ohm per meter. Energy loss, ie current actual quantity reduction, by energy exchange to heat in the water, is 10% in 50 meters. So if the depth of water is 50 meters and stray current is at 10 milliamps your vessel will receive 9 milli amps (0.009 amp). We commonly measure 100 milli amps and I have personally measured 9 amps of stray current. We flash red, on a 12 volt vessel at 1 milliamp. If your vessel is generating stray current it will pass to every vessel within 100 meters, causing electrolysis of all wet metal, engine manifolds, propeller hull glands, rudders …
3.Switches.We have chosen the switches by PROVEN quality. WE don’t want any on site problems and switches are one area to be thought about carefully.
1200 cranking amps. I assume this is peak current figure, not RMS but please correct me if I am wrong. Typically there is a 10 to 1 ratio. So 1200 cranking amps has an RMS value of 120 amps.For verification see
http://www.amelec.com.au...=batteryswitches-manual and download their PDF on specifications.
Choice of switch for medium to large diesel or large petrol see
http://www.seabis.net/productlist.htm and scroll down to Manual Battery Switches as options, with current ratings – actual proven ratings of RMS 275 to 350 amps, in cranking current peak terms 2750 to 3500 amps. For higher current ratings please contact me. Be wary if the seller quotes 2500 amps. Peak or RMS???
I hope I have answered your questions. Text is more difficult to pass detail as response is much slower and often less accurate. There is photographic proof at
www.seabis.com.au Related links: Proof…
Regards,
Glen Bishop marine engineer
61 (0)8 8556 6593
info@seabis.net