|
|
Rank: New Poster
Groups: Member
Joined: 2/27/2008
Posts: 9
Points: 27
Location: Battle Creek, MI
|
We have a 1988 32 flybridge. The Bennett trim tab pump finally gave out. I spoke with Bennett and they have a trade in program for th pump for $188. I was down in the back getting ready to pull the pump when my neighbor asked what I was doing. He is a fishing charter captain. He said he went through 2 pumps over the years and also saw some performance issues.
He searched and found electric actuators that replace the bennett pistons and uses the same mounting holes as well as the electric wire passes through the hull where the hydraulic tubing was. He said solid performance and quicker response. I can get the upgrade or changeout kit for $250.
I am thinking this is the way to go. Easier to maintain in the future.
Anyone have any experience or thoughts?
Thanks,
Gregg
|
|
|
|
Please Register : New members may not post until approved. An email is sent after approval. We do this to reduce those who use these forums for spamming.
This forum is for Marinette Owners and other aluminum boat boaters who wish to share boating information. Aluminum Roamer owners are also welcome. (Do not post content you do not have the right to post and mass (robots) posters are unwelcome. We also have a marine electronics page and lots of Chrysler Engine info. State by what permission, you copy content and accredit properly.) The site is now fixed with some more Chrysler information. I will try to post more information soon. We have space for pictures on the new location. Use shinkpic to autochange size http://www.onthegosoft.com/sp_download.htm
Great Sites - http://www.marinette.com Marinette Company
http://www.geocities.com/dougmrose/ Wiring Marinette
http://fastjeff.tripod.com/ Repair Tricks and Techniques for Marinettes
http://www.greatlakesmarinetteclub.com/
PLEASE post in the appropriate folder. Please, do not post your actual email address in publicly readable websites.
The first rule is be a class act.
|
|
Rank: Top Rank Aluminum Star
Groups: Member
Joined: 9/11/2008
Posts: 281
Points: 300
Location: mebane,nc
|
sounds good have your got a link so we all can see them.mine work but ate sloooow and seem to draw a lot of power.
tim
72 32' express
"http://www.theboaters.com/boats/Powerboat_Express_Cruiser_marinette_1972_anticipation"
|
|
Rank: Top Rank Aluminum Star
Groups: Member
Joined: 12/16/2007
Posts: 403
Points: 981
Location: Petersburg, Illinois
|
interested in that link also.
Roger
The trouble with getting old, There is a lot of info in memory, I either can't find it or don't trust it if I do!
|
|
Rank: Administration
Groups: Administration
, Member, Other Mods
Joined: 12/4/2007
Posts: 673
Points: 847
Location: Potomac MD
|
old32 wrote:mine work but are sloooow and seem to draw a lot of power.tim What do you have - hydraulic or electric tabs. MEanwhile, keep in mind that Bennett has excellent reputation for standing behind its products.
Joel Albert, Potomac MD
"Charlie B" - 32' FBS
docked Deale, MD
|
|
Rank: New Poster
Groups: Member
Joined: 2/27/2008
Posts: 9
Points: 27
Location: Battle Creek, MI
|
Here is a link to the retrofit kit on Lenco's site. http://www.lencomarine.com/bennettretrofit.htmlThey also have their version of why electric is better than hydraulic. Hope this helps!
|
|
Rank: Top Rank Aluminum Star
Groups: Member
Joined: 9/11/2008
Posts: 281
Points: 300
Location: mebane,nc
|
joel i don't know what kind i have but they are hyd has a pump with two valves .may be original from 72.
tim
72 32' express
"http://www.theboaters.com/boats/Powerboat_Express_Cruiser_marinette_1972_anticipation"
|
|
Rank: Administration
Groups: Administration
, Member, Other Mods
Joined: 12/4/2007
Posts: 673
Points: 847
Location: Potomac MD
|
If you took sharp photo of pump and posted, folks here could probably tell you brand. That's what I think you mean when you say you don't know what "kind" you have. My bet is that you have Bennett which has long been quite popular. But I know what you are asking, that is an opinion from someone who has had both types about their durability, operation, and ease of repair.
One con I can see with hydraulic type is that they can develop leaks which requires hose changes. I've never had that problem to my knowledge and they just keep chugging on.
Joel Albert, Potomac MD
"Charlie B" - 32' FBS
docked Deale, MD
|
|
Rank: Top Rank Aluminum Star
Groups: Member
, Other Mods
Joined: 12/4/2007
Posts: 447
Points: 1,337
Location: Catawba IS. Ohio
|
Lencos comparison. http://www.lencomarine.com/compareelectricv.htmlBennetts comparison. http://www.bennetttrimtabs.com/hydraulicvselectric.phpIn my opinion the hydraulic system seems much less complicated, simpler than electrical. -Karl
1986, 32' Sedan, twin 360ci, 275hp Chrysler's w/ K&N flame arrestors Original Site Member Since: 5/18/1999. Original Site Posts: 1262
|
|
Rank: Top Rank Aluminum Star
Groups: Member
Joined: 12/4/2007
Posts: 207
Points: -143
Location: Lake Barkley
|
I have had both types.. on different vessels. My own experience.. Bennett hands down. Seldom if ever needs repair... unit on my M is 23 years and going strong. Super support and great folks to deal with!
dave
|
|
Rank: Top Rank Aluminum Star
Groups: Member
Joined: 12/7/2007
Posts: 753
Points: 935
Location: Central Florida and the DC area
|
When I bought my '75 32', I knew that the 25-year-old Bennett trim tabs would need replacement, and I was ready to spend the money. But, a little fiddling with the wiring brought them back to life, and they are on the boat still!
"I remember when welfare was for poor people..."
|
|
Rank: Top Rank Aluminum Star
Groups: Administration
, Member
Joined: 12/5/2007
Posts: 2,018
Points: 3,869
Location: New Tripoli, PA
|
The Bennett people are very nice!
Jeff
Only 40 days 'til splash time!
|
|
|
Guest2 |
