(Jeff: I think he was talking about actual fuel amount to refill, not using the gauges).
I had the same problem two seasons ago. Turned out that the port engine was mis-timed. It was consuming 15% more fuel on some fillups. Now, they are virtually identical. Of course, there are reasons other than timing to account for one engine sucking up fuel - good luck in your search for the cause.
Joel Albert, Potomac MD
"Charlie B" - 1988 32' FBS
Twin 318's/FWC/16x15 nibral props
docked Deale, MD