I believe It's a personal choice , if you use the boat as a condo and just cruise every now then either one well work i'm sure. As for me, i prefer the paint like Norm said. Always have a couple of boats hooked to us, large and smaller; no matter how many fenders , will end up with some scrapes and dings. Brewskies don't help either. Power buffing wheels never showed me anything that looked good on a paint job, always swirls left. No matter what you decide will probable last you awhile. Hell ,they want $ 8.00 a FT. just to paint the stripes here at our marina. God knows mine needs a paint job, but thats whats not next.
Mark
No matter where you go,there you are.
Knot Normal
28FT. Express
Twin 318's
Ten Mile Tn.