Jeff:
We are both right!
1. CME requirements do not ALWAY follow CFR exactly. There are items on the CME list which are optional and not required by law. For years I had to deal with Aux volunteers which 99 percent of the time were great. The other 1 percent were a pain.(always a couple of wanna bees in every group) I arrested three in my career for actually stopping and boarding vessel while underway. Also I had one guy that always failed if they did not have a bailing bucket on board thats ok but then told folks they could not launch at our state ramp! While a bucket for emergency bailing is a great idea and I have several on board, there is not Federal requirement and probably no state requirement that I am aware of.
Boats built prior to 1980 are NOT required to have powered ventalation.
That would include the majority of or big Ms
Here is the CFR source for review:
http://www.boatboymarinetraining.com/pdf/USCG_Required_Equip.pdf
Ok for those that wish to dive into this often confusing topic here are the safety USCG safety bulletins dealing with the subject in 33 CFR
After dealing with this issue for 30 years I still got confused and basicly If it had ventalation of either type I considered it an educational opportunity unless it was factory installed incorrectly. I knew if a judge had to wade through all this he would never rule in favor of the state at a bench trial and no way if it ever went to jury.
http://www.uscgboating.org/assets/pdf/recalls/BSC69.pdf
safe boating dave
None