Sounds like you have to work back. My boat is a in Lake Barkley and I also boat in KY lake.
After three years (three full summers) my readings have gone down a little.
.65-.72. I replaced anodes at last haul out and readings were up to .95 for the past 2 summers.
I have growth on bottom and am losing continuity between anodes and cathode so I added mag guppy this summer.
With guppy redings jumped up to 1.05 and are steady.
Now it sounds like you have either an isolation problem (since guppy is not changing readings) or your silver silver Chloride cathode has been damaged or painted over. also sometimes the single wire which is going to the cathode is disconnected broked or just damaged.
When I haul in a week for paint I will clean anodes and assuming they are still in good shape my hull readings should come up to normal without the guppy.
one test is take a jumper wire and have helper push activate your meter while you intentionaly ground the shaft to the hull or the engne the block. If the meter deflects downward they your shafts are properly isolated. If not they are not isolated and they will lower your readings and you will be unprotected.
You can check with an ohm meter also. Check for continuity between shaft coupler. There should not be continuity. There will be a very small amount o ohms but not enough to activiate a tone.
Also clean your anodes and see if the readingts change. Readings underway are not reliable and it can take several hours for readings to come up while at anchor.
Through process of elimination you should find the ground fault.
dave
None